Skip to content

OK, this is strange…

I don’t want to be unnecessarily Microsoft bashing here, but take a look at these two identical web searches on Google and Live Search:

First, Google (click to enlarge).

Google search for free software

Now the same search on Windows Live Search (or whatever it’s called now):

Live Search for free software

Notice that in the Windows Live Search one, there is absolutely no mention of free software as in the freedom type. Not even a scrap of evidence that the FSF exist.

Now, either Windows Live Search is worse than I originally thought, or there’s some kind of conspiracy thing going on here. I hope for Microsoft’s sake it’s the former.

If it were the latter, I would be very worried.

It’s not Google being quirky either, Yahoo also list the FSF as the top result for the same query.

Do the searches yourself – on Live Search, Google and Yahoo.

UPDATE: turns out this only happens when Live Search is set to weight UK results (like when you come from a UK-based IP address through Live.com). More info.

Like this post?

If you would like to support the time and effort I have put into my tutorials and writing, please consider making a donation.

3 Comments

  1. Lee wrote:

    That is strange, I’ve just done a search for “free software” and the first result was the FSF, although according to thie site I was logged in, maybe there is a conspiracy!

    Wednesday, March 28, 2007 at 21:21 | Permalink | Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.3 on Windows Windows Vista
  2. Chris wrote:

    FSF is the first result for me on Live Search.

    Wednesday, March 28, 2007 at 21:29 | Permalink | Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.3 on Mac OS Mac OS
  3. Peter wrote:

    Got it.

    If you bounce through live.com from a UK IP address, it presumably prioritises UK results and the search for some reason (still unknown) excludes the FSF.

    If you go to search.msn.com (or bounce through a non-UK IP), it sets the mkt value in the URL to mkt=en-us, so no UK weighting on results. Then it returns the FSF as the first hit.

    For privacy reasons, when I posted the link to do the search, I stripped out all URL key/value pairs except the actual query, which removes the UK weighting and the FSF comes it at number 1. Here’s the the original search link.

    I guess I should have checked my URLs carefully before posting 🙂

    Still, it leaves an unanswered question – why no FSF in the UK?

    Wednesday, March 28, 2007 at 21:39 | Permalink | Using Mozilla Firefox Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.3 on Mac OS Mac OS

One Trackback/Pingback

  1. Linspire :: Blog :: Peter Upfold on Thursday, June 14, 2007 at 15:24

    […] a bit ironic they’re setting a search engine which on the UK version can’t find the FSF on a query for ‘free software’ as the default. On what is supposed to be a free […]

Post a Comment

On some sites, you must be logged in to post a comment. This is not the case on this site.
Your email address is not made public or shared. Required fields are marked with *.
*
*
*

Posting a comment signifies you accept the privacy policy.
Please note — usually your comment will appear straight away but sometimes it will be held for approval (this is due to the spam filter). If your comment is waiting to be approved, please don’t post it again! It will appear eventually.